Attention Isn't Missing. It's Variable.

An editorial from The Economist is making the rounds again on social media. It ran in 2024 under the headline "ADHD should not be treated as a disorder," and a friend recently sent it to me to ask what I thought.

My short answer: it holds up, and research published since then makes it even more relevant. As the parent of a child with ADHD, I've seen what happens when a bright, creative kid hears over and over what's wrong with him and rarely what's right. So when a mainstream publication with no stake in the ADHD world argues that the way we think about ADHD needs to change, I pay attention.

What The Economist gets right

The editorial's core argument is that we treat ADHD as all-or-nothing: you either have it or you don't. The science doesn't support that anymore. Researchers haven't found a single "ADHD brain." The traits we group under the label, such as trouble sustaining attention, impulsivity, and difficulty organizing daily life, fall along a wide spectrum, much like any other human trait.

The yes-or-no approach causes two problems, according to the piece:

  1. It overwhelms the system. In England, some people wait up to ten years just for an assessment. Here in the U.S., it can take six months to a year, which can feel like ten years when you or your kid are struggling and don't know why.

  2. It frames people as broken. When ADHD is treated as a dysfunction to be fixed, people spend enormous energy forcing themselves to look "normal." That effort is exhausting and is linked to anxiety and depression. It also wastes a great deal of talent.

The alternative the editors propose is one I believe in deeply: for many people, ADHD challenges ease a lot when their environment works with their brain instead of against it. They point to schools in Portsmouth, England, where teachers map each child's strengths and support needs without waiting for a diagnosis. They also list simple changes that help: mixing sitting, standing, and group work; flexible start times; bullet-point summaries; noise-cancelling headphones; quiet corners.

None of that is expensive. All of it is human.

I especially loved one point. People with ADHD traits are often specialists, not generalists. They may struggle in a big meeting or a noisy classroom and still be exceptional at work that needs deep focus or attention to detail. The smart move is to build around those strengths and hand off the rest.

What newer research adds

Since the editorial ran, two large studies have pointed in the same direction.

  • Attention may not be the core problem. In a study published in Cell in December 2025, Dr. Benjamin Kay of Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis analyzed brain imaging from more than 5,000 children ages 8 to 11. Stimulant medication appeared to act mainly on the brain's reward and alertness networks, not on the attention circuitry researchers had long assumed. Kay's takeaway: kids with ADHD don't simply lack attention. Their attention is selective, and it can be hard to engage. (That doesn't mean medication doesn't help. It may help by making boring, effortful tasks easier to stick with.)

  • Attention runs on a spectrum. A 2026 study in the Journal of Attention Disorders, led by researchers at the University of Calgary, looked at brain connectivity in more than 7,000 children ages 9 and 10. The link between attention ability and brain connectivity looked the same whether or not a child had an ADHD diagnosis. The authors read that as attention forming one continuous spectrum across all kids.

Neither study is the final word. But both line up with the editorial's central point: ADHD is less a box you're in or out of than a different relationship with attention and reward.

What this doesn't mean

The editorial doesn’t claim that ADHD isn't real, or that medication and therapy don't matter. It says plainly that for people at the more severe end, treatment can be essential for finishing school, keeping a job, and staying safe. Medication is a valid, often life-changing choice.

The point is that support shouldn't begin and end with a label. Most people need understanding and a better fit with their surroundings at least as much as they need a diagnosis.

Why the name matters: from ADHD to VAST

This is also why I'm a fan of the alternative term Dr. Ned Hallowell and Dr. John Ratey introduced in their 2021 book ADHD 2.0: VAST, or Variable Attention Stimulus Trait.

Think about the words in "attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder." Deficit suggests something is missing. Disorder suggests something is broken. The attention challenges are real. But attention isn't missing. It's variable, and it's driven by interest. The trouble is that not everything we need to get done is interesting.

My son is a perfect example. He loves fishing, which, honestly, I find boring. He can stand at the water for hours and still beg to stay longer. But ask him to read for his assigned 20 minutes of homework each night and you'd think I was asking him to do something painful. Same kid, same brain. The difference is interest.

Words shape identity, especially for kids. A child who grows up hearing "you have a disorder" learns a very different story about themselves than one who hears "your brain is wired for stimulation, so let's figure out how to make that work for you." Less shame and more curiosity: that's the shift.

What this looks like in coaching

This is the heart of how I work. Instead of asking "What's wrong with me?", we ask better questions:

  • When does focus come easily for me, and what's different about those moments?

  • What drains my energy fastest, and can I change the setting instead of forcing myself through it?

  • Which tasks play to my strengths, and which can I delegate, automate, or restructure?

  • What does a day built for my brain actually look like?

The answers are different for everyone. That's the point.

Work with your brain, not against it. If you, or someone you love, is ready to stop fighting their wiring and start building around it, I'd love to help.

Sources: "ADHD should not be treated as a disorder," The Economist, Oct. 30, 2024 (read it here) · Kay et al., Cell, December 2025 · Harkness et al., Journal of Attention Disorders, 2026 · Hallowell & Ratey, ADHD 2.0 (2021)

Next
Next

The Women We Miss: Why ADHD Hides in Plain Sight